Oct 7, 2009

I am sorry if this post comes across as a rant. I don't have the energy to be funny right now.
***

For the last three months, I've been subject to Tamil serials in the evenings - from when I come back to work until ten-thirty. Thankfully, work ensures I get home only by nine-thirty on most days. Tamil serials are loud, brash, depressing. Characters only show the most disgusting emotions - of hate, jealousy, taking offence (a la the Culture Vultures), anger, 'honour', revenge.

The "bad" are intolerably bad - they always (and I mean ALWAYS) talk as if they're scheming (For instance, there was this scene where an evil mother-in-law was asking the cook to get milk for her granddaughter. She somehow made even that line sound evil!). Usually in the pettiest of manners. For instance, there is this lady who is behaving like she's unwell so that she can take advantage of her divorced daughter-in-law who takes pity on her. There's this other lady (in another serial) who (with her son) is trying to play some really really random politics in her brother's house - like creating a huge fuss when her nephew buys some expensive (Rs. 6000) jewellery for his wife. There was this other scene where the man's family troubles his pregnant wife only because she's earning and her husband is jealous of the whole deal. They complain that the coffee she's made is watery, that the cups in her house are too small, that the house is too uncomfortable.

Then there's all the ridiculous corporate battles they fight. Where they kill each other off without any trouble or remorse. Nobody is ever happy. Nobody is ever nice to another person. Except the VICTIM. The VICTIM is a central character who is simply too nice to everyone around her. (No, the VICTIM is never a man. A correct reflection of society, although a bit exaggerated.) Her niceness is always taken advantage of. People are always screwing her over. Always. And she still finds the strength to be intolerably nice to everyone. Only, she cries so much that you'd prefer her just getting screwed over instead of trying to be nice about it.

I wont even begin on the gender issues - every stereotype is reinforced. The thaali sentiment, dowry (In one serial going on right now, a wedding is stalled due to dowry issues, and not one voice is raised against the practice itself. Not even in the households watching these serials, I bet.) (Ok. Right now, as I type, the mother and daughter are having major issues because the daughter spilt rasam, thereby creating food shortages in the household.) Then there's the ubiquitous chinna veedu (literally, small house - "second family" of a man). Everyone seems to have one. And the domestic political possibilities of such a situation seem endless. There are always people to be jealous about, people to cry for, people to kill, illegitimacy and status to squabble over.

The music - can it be a little less harmful on the ear? Slightly?

I know that Tamilians as a class are highly petty people. But even by those standards, these serials are a bit much. Surely there are better stories to tell, no?

18 replies:

Anonymous said...

Being only slightly familiar with the content of the soaps themselves, I see that they have a lot of influence over the people that watch them. It makes certain people I know more likely to enforce those negative stereotypes.

I think televisions contribute to this social conservatism. I've seen it happen firsthand. It's kind of strange that people confuse bad soaps and cinematography for real life.

(But I'm totally convinced that only Crest toothpaste can get at the plaque between my teeth, so mindfudgery happens everywhere and to everyone.)

As for the awful, screeching headache-inducing music I'm at a loss.

Sreya said...

Goddamn, the previous comment was mine.

Suhas said...

(It's) also funny how people we hold in high regard are hopelessly glued to this stuff. Remember your 'mediocrity suffers' theory? It works in more ways than we imagine, maybe?

As long as the target audience get their nightly fix, and Ekta is laughing all the way to the bank, everyone's happy I guess.

Sreya said...

Suhas, that was exactly what I was thinking! (In terms of people I highly regard, I mean.)

As for Ekta; is she the woman who's responsible for Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu thi? That woman should be arrested for crimes against humanity!

Anonymous said...

yours says it all. all, actually.

sandeip said...

true for all serials made on those themes-across languages on indian TV.

I guess the fact that they get made, says something about those who see the serials,or at least what those who make them think about those who see them- the kindest interpretation is that we have become so dumb that we need to see the world through unidimentional lenses...

aandthirtyeights said...

@Anonymous Sreya
As God put it once, "Life doesn't imitate art. It imitates bad television."

@Suhas
Um, I'm not happy!! :P

@Sreya
If only the world were that just.

@thenitknumbskulls
Have you written a post on this somewhere?

@sandeip
Had the same conversation with my grandparents last night - tried asking them why they would watch something like this. Their only response was "Timepass." So, I told them, twice a week, I'll take them to a concert so that they don't have to watch this. They refused to come!

Ketaki said...

I don't hate anyone as much as I hate "Abhi" the victim... Do you know Abhi? Do you hate Abhi??

aandthirtyeights said...

Kets, I HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE Abhi. :)

Anonymous said...

@aandthirtyeights
No. I don't have enough knowledge of the subject to do so. I lapse into convulsions when i'm brought anywhere close to where a soap is playing, irrespective of language. my palms clench into fists, my forehead creases like a folded roadmap, my teeth gnash and i scream "WHY WHY WHY" every single moment i'm watching my grandmother watch balika vadhu or arasi or kolangal. or innumerable others.
i began watching kanaa kaanum kaalangal thanks to many positive recos from friends.... but it seemed just as bad as the others. the pettiness and kadi-joke-ness gets on your nerves really bad.

s said...

this time when i came home, i found ammamma watching a telugu soap with achyutha. i was just dumbstruck. what in the world could a seven year old boy see in a telugu soap?

buddy said...

ah! the tamil serial
you forgot past lives and daughters across seasons

Maya said...

Just my thoughts! Wrote a chapter on this when I spoke to a few among family and friends who watch such serials. All of them were a little sheepish about their viewing habits and all said that they were doing it just for 'timepass'. But I noticed that some actually displayed 'withdrawal symptoms' when they could not get their daily dose for whatever reason, like say power cut or visitors at home! Perhaps, we should do a 'before' (serial watching) and 'after' experiment to find out just how much these serials can skew a persons' thinking!!!!

aandthirtyeights said...

@thenitknumbskulls
Kanaa Kaanum Kaalangam started off well. But it turned into a sob-soap at the school level very soon. Yes.

@s
He sees the world in that soap, Sou.

@buddy
Haha! Daughters across seasons!

@Maya
I've seen people around change with all these serials. That experiment might not be a bad idea!

Divya said...

Yeah Tam serials are particularly bad and negative I think. Have you seen 'Yengay Brahmana'? (spelling is probably wrong). Its particularly disturbing.

physica said...

Hilarious! I think it is funnier if you are not subjected to it.

BTW, I found out from a Japanese roommate that Japanese soaps are primarily mom & daughter-in law based. My landlady was telling me about a Spanish soap, where an evil lady had cheated a man's family and banished his daughter... She urged me to watch it too (she volunteered doing the translation).

There might be something common in soaps all over the world.

LS said...

I have hoped for a while now that some gender rights NGO would sue the makers of these serials. The storylines break laws at three-minute intervals -- bigamy, dowry, emotional abuse -- and, what’s infinitely worse, it’s all held up as a grand example of glorious womanhood. Isn’t there a clear conflict here with all the government-sponsored public interest messages that say the girl child is precious and so on? Surely, there's a case here somewhere.

What freaks me out is that not all young people have access to a more liberal point of view, and can actually be persuaded to believe that they have no choice. I know of a young girl, a distant cousin, trapped in a miserable marriage of the sort that would give these serials a run for their ratings -- she has a Masters degree but, unbelievably, she hasn’t left the jerk and his abominable family. I can only imagine she considers Abhi some sort of an icon. The implication of that boggles my mind.

Also, the ‘timepass’ excuse (I have heard it too) doesn’t wash. I think that deep down inside, the folk who are able to tolerate these stories actually believe in the rubbish. Which probably explains why Cho is held up to be some sort of intellectual and hopes for ‘the restoration of Brahmin honour’ are pinned on Yenge Brahmanan. Unfathomably, loyalists tend to have a rather high opinion of their own intelligence.

aandthirtyeights said...

@Divya
Heh. Enge Brahmanan. Yes. That was a phase.

@physica
I wonder if all this has to do with the target audience...

@LS
There is a story I must tell you. Will tell you some day.